New Zealand, Europe and America: useful comparisons, different farms

Overseas producers offer lessons about risk and market exposure—not a ready-made South African milk-price forecast.

Key points

New Zealand season growth is a forecast, not an achieved annual result. [1]
The EU raw-milk benchmark was €42.8 per 100 kg in August. [2]
USDA’s US$19.90 per cwt is a 2026 annual all-milk price forecast. [3]

Key figures

New Zealand production outlook: Around +1% — 2026/27 forecast reported by AHDB from Rabobank; weather-dependent [1]
EU raw milk: €42.8/100 kg — August 2026 EU dashboard benchmark; +2.3% from preceding month [2]
US all-milk price: US$19.90/cwt — USDA October forecast for calendar 2026; cwt is US hundredweight, not litres [3]

New Zealand: seasonal opportunity and weather risk

AHDB’s account of Rabobank’s third-quarter outlook says New Zealand began the 2026/27 season with strong momentum, with June and July setting new monthly production records. It attributes the pattern to favourable weather, greater adoption of autumn calving and extended winter milking. The report forecasts production growth of around 1% for the season, dependent on the developing El Niño pattern. [1]

The distinction between observation and forecast is essential. Strong early months do not settle the full-season result. AHDB also reports that Southeast Asian demand helped absorb additional production and support farm-gate prices. It does not supply a current nationwide New Zealand payout that this edition can safely compare with a South African payment. A verified current New Zealand payout in NZ dollars per kilogram of milk solids was unavailable. [1]

For South African producers, the transferable lesson is analytical rather than numerical: match the production calendar to feed availability, weather exposure and the buyer’s requirements. A reported seasonal advantage overseas is not proof that shifting calving dates will improve returns locally. That decision needs farm-specific reproductive, feed and contract information.

Europe: raw milk and products must stay separate

The European Commission dashboard reports an EU raw-milk price of €42.8 per 100 kg for August 2026, 2.3% above the preceding month. The same dashboard carries separate weekly quotations for processed products. A raw-milk benchmark and a butter quotation refer to different goods, even when both are expressed per 100 kg. Neither should be relabelled as a South African rand-per-litre farm-gate price. [2]

EU cows’ milk collections increased 3.0% in January–August compared with the same period of 2025. That regional increase can coexist with pressure on individual farms: it describes aggregate collections rather than the distribution of profits, debt or weather effects. A representative current EU dairy-farm profitability estimate was unavailable in the evidence verified for this issue. [4]

The applicable lesson is to compare a system, not just a headline payment. As analysis, milk composition, purchased-feed reliance, energy use, capital costs and contract arrangements all affect the meaning of a price comparison. Simply translating euros into rand leaves these differences unresolved, especially when the original milk measure is weight rather than volume.

United States: forecast prices, not guaranteed margins

USDA’s 19 October update forecasts US milk production at 236.9 billion pounds in 2026 and 238.4 billion pounds in 2027. Its projected all-milk price is US$19.90 per hundredweight for 2026 and US$20.45 for 2027. These are calendar-year forecasts, not October spot transactions or guaranteed payments to every producer. [3]

USDA lowered its 2026 production forecast because of reduced expectations for both cow inventories and milk per cow in the second half. This illustrates why revisions deserve attention even when the broad supply narrative seems settled. The reported all-milk price alone does not establish a producer margin; a current representative US profit figure was not verified here. [3]

Across all three regions, the useful comparison is the relationship between realised milk revenue, controllable costs and exposure to shocks. The non-transferable part is the assumption that an overseas price or policy environment applies unchanged to South Africa. Keep currencies, units, periods and forecast status visible. With the available evidence, the honest conclusion is a set of lessons about measurement and risk—not a ranking of which country’s dairy farmers are currently most profitable.

Sources

[1] AHDB: Global Supply Growth Eases, Rabobank Q3 dairy outlook — 2026/27 season forecast and early-season observations (Exact publication date unavailable; Q3 2026 outlook)
[2] European Commission: dairy dashboard — Raw milk August 2026; commodity quotations week 43 (Exact publication date unavailable; includes week 43 of 2026)
[3] USDA ERS: Dairy Market Outlook — 2026 and 2027 forecasts (2026-10-19 (page update))
[4] European Commission: milk production development — January–August 2026 versus January–August 2025 (Exact publication date unavailable)

This article first appeared in Economic Trends Issue 1, MaxMedia's digital magazine on dairy economics.

Back to all articles